Division swap!
Monday, July 31st, 2006The map below shows the distance from Pittsburgh to all the cities with Major League Baseball teams in the National League Central and National League East divisions. Mileage was calculated using city-to-city driving directions with Google Maps.
The Pirates are in the Central division, but they quite clearly shouldn’t be.
To start, Pittsburgh is farther east than Atlanta. No other teams in Major League Baseball are similarly miscategorized. Every team in the AL West is farther west than every team in the AL Central, and every team in the AL Central is farther west than every team in the AL East. All NL West teams are appropriately western. Only the NL East and Central have this problem. Moving the Pirates to the NL East would solve it and restore geographical logic to the league.
Second, Pittsburgh is closer, on average, to NL East teams (mean: 556 miles; median: 370 miles) than to NL Central teams (mean: 662 miles; median: 551 miles). Surely some of the Pirates’ lackluster performance can be attributed to the unnecessarily long distances they have to travel between cities in their own division!
Third, the NL Central is the only MLB division with six teams. All others have five, except the AL West, which gets away with only four. No fair! The Wild Card is some consolation, but it’s certainly still easier to get to the playoffs by winning a four- or five-team division than a six-team division. NL Central teams deserve a break, and the Pirates, with their total inability to win games, are just the team to shift the burden. NL Central teams might appreciate the smaller division, and NL East teams would get an unthreatening punching bag to play with every few weeks. Everybody wins! (Of course, point three works under the assumption that the Braves would stay in the NL East.)
Fourth, I live in Washington and would like to see my hometown team come to RFK more often.